Thread:SodaCat/@comment-5385060-20151031062626/@comment-5385060-20151031072436

I also came up with an idea. It is off topic to the first post of this message, but I thought it best to put the idea here than start a whole new thread.

How about an in wiki club? Basically, this centers around giving advice on how to improve writing and so forth. This method was introduced on a site I frequented for a while, before joining here. That was much different because it was a proper forum, but we can do the same principle.

My idea, there will be a proper forum board on this wiki, specically for the club. This club offers advice. If a user feels their story is lacking something, the other members could offer their advice. Users could make a thread, posting the link to the chapter, and the members constructively review the chapter, from a perspective to help them improve.

This could be anything from characters, to stories, chapters, even story concepts users are unsure of.

The idea really took off. Because in all writing communities there are people who genuinely want to help others, but not all other members of the community want to hear it. Some just want people say all is great, or just get a chance to talk to people about what happened in the chapter, and others want help. This will give those that want help to get it.

Not all of it has to be critisim either. The forum this worked on, the members of the club focused on pointing out what the writer had done right, telling them they no longer need to focus there, and offered up suggestions how to make all other areas of their stories just as great.

There can be a membership thing, where users can either join to offer out advice, or just stop by to offer up their works for the club members to look over and review. All reviews are done in the comments section of the page or blog. If need be, I can make a userbox for members of the club, because I gained experience making them on Sims wiki.

I know this wiki is small, but I think this will help. I was going to post this on the board for the suggestions, but I wanted to get your thoughts, before it is suggested to everyone else.